FSCAC, May 2024: the committee approves its first annual report and picks barriers to entry and faster approvals as its next priorities
On May 20, 2024, the Federal Secure Cloud Advisory Committee approved its first annual report, 12 to 0. It then chose two priorities: barriers to entry, with a focus on small businesses, and faster, cheaper approvals. Its advice is not a rule.
By FedXchange ·
Play the video: Federal Secure Cloud Advisory Committee (FSCAC) May 20, 2024 MeetingOn May 20, 2024, the Federal Secure Cloud Advisory Committee (FSCAC) met in person in Washington, DC, with a live stream for people online. The FSCAC is the advisory committee that the FedRAMP Authorization Act requires. It gives advice and recommendations to the Administrator of the General Services Administration (GSA), the FedRAMP Board, and agencies. FedRAMP is the Federal Risk and Authorization Management Program. The committee's recommendations are advice. They do not change FedRAMP's rules.
The Federal Register notice said the meeting was for reviewing the committee's annual report and for choosing its next priorities.
The meeting came before the FedRAMP Consolidated Rules for 2026. In 2024, FedRAMP's approval was called a "FedRAMP authorization," and members used that term. The current terms are "FedRAMP Certification" and "FedRAMP Certified." FedRAMP's What's Changing in 2026 page says the new term avoids confusing a FedRAMP approval with an agency's authorization to operate (ATO).
Quotations in this post are words from the meeting recording, checked against its captions. The post names speakers by their role.
In short:
- What the committee decided. Members approved the committee's first annual report to Congress and the GSA Administrator. GSA's minutes record 12 votes in favor, none opposed, and no abstentions.
- What it chose to work on. Two priorities: barriers to entry for cloud service providers (CSPs), with a focus on small businesses, and ways to speed up approval and cut its cost. The minutes record 7 votes in favor, 1 opposed, and 4 abstentions.
- What members added. Under both priorities, members included evaluating and giving guidance on minimum standardized baselines for sponsoring agencies and third party assessment organizations (3PAOs).
- What it means for agencies and cloud providers. Nothing changed at the time. The vote set the topics for the committee's later advice to the GSA Administrator, the FedRAMP Board, and agencies.
Sources: the May 20, 2024, meeting video, GSA's minutes, the FSCAC annual report, and GSA's FSCAC meetings page. The committee's recommendations are advice, not FedRAMP rules.
Read the steps as text
- March 28, 2024. Members heard updates on the Office of Management and Budget's draft FedRAMP memo and discussed possible next priorities.
- May 1, 2024. GSA appointed four members, one of them reappointed.
- May 20, 2024. Members approved the annual report to Congress and the GSA Administrator, 12 to 0.
- May 20, 2024. Members chose two priorities, 7 in favor, 1 opposed, and 4 abstaining, and decided not to form subcommittees.
- July 16, 2024. The committee held its next meeting.
What is in the committee's first annual report?
The law requires the committee to send a report to the GSA Administrator and Congress within 540 days of the law's enactment, and every year after that. In the meeting, the chair said the first report was due June 14, 2024.
The annual report covers December 2022 to May 2024. It lists two deliverables the committee approved:
- A November 2023 feedback letter on the Office of Management and Budget's (OMB's) draft memo, "Modernizing the Federal Risk and Authorization Management Program." It raised concerns about small business costs and asked for clearer terms.
- A February 2024 recommendations memo on the committee's 2023 priorities: the CSP authorization path, continuous monitoring, and automation.
The report also counts 11 open meetings and 21 public comments.
Before the vote, the member from the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) asked about Appendix A. It holds individual members' comments without names, and the member worried readers would take them as the committee's view. The Designated Federal Officer said the appendix already states that the comments may not reflect the views of all members. The chair moved to approve the report as written, and it passed.
What did the public ask for?
Two people spoke. A member of Red Hat's FedRAMP team asked the committee to ask for faster, more modern FedRAMP guidance:
"For instance, the authorization boundary guidance has been in draft phase since July 2021." — Public commenter from Red Hat
A speaker from Okta said about 30 agencies and authorizing officials (AOs) take part in its FedRAMP Moderate offering. The speaker asked FedRAMP for guidance on how agencies should organize after the Joint Authorization Board (JAB), and whether a multiagency authorization would be equal to a JAB authorization.
Which priorities did the committee choose, and why?
The chair said three priorities got the most votes in a tally of members' top preferences. Members spent about 45 minutes on the wording before they voted.
Who the first priority covers. A member asked whether it should cover all CSPs, not only small businesses. Another member said small businesses are particularly disadvantaged. Members settled on CSPs in general, with a focus on small businesses.
What a "minimum risk threshold" means. The member from the Defense Information Systems Agency (DISA) said they did not understand the third priority, because risk depends on how an agency uses a service. A member from Schellman, an assessor, explained the idea: if every sponsoring agency met a minimum standard, FedRAMP might not need a second full review. The member said that second review is "partially what's drawing out all of the very extended FedRAMP queues that we have." A FedRAMP staff member then clarified:
"we're not trying to necessarily offer a minimum like risk threshold, but more of a standardized methodology that can be applied regardless of the path." — FedRAMP Program Management Office staff member
Guidance for small providers. The member from Project Hosts, a cloud provider, said small providers without compliance staff pay consultants to fill gaps in FedRAMP's guidance, which adds cost:
"And the agency says, 'Go talk to FedRAMP.' And FedRAMP says, 'Go ask your agency AO.' And CSPs are just stuck in the middle" — FSCAC member from Project Hosts
A member also said CISA had worked with FedRAMP on a threat modeling method that could rank controls by real threats.
Members then merged the third priority into the first two. The approved motion has two priorities. The first is barriers to entry for CSPs, with a focus on small businesses, 3PAOs, and small and large agencies. The second is ways to expedite the certification process, including agile authorizations and lower labor and financial costs. Each includes a sub-item: evaluate and provide guidance for "a minimum risk threshold, minimum acceptability standardized baselines for sponsoring agencies and 3PAOs," as the chair read it in the motion.
Why did some members object?
A member from Google suggested standard timelines for agency reviews. The member from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) said tight budgets made that unrealistic for small agencies:
"now you're suggesting that large businesses and small businesses should be competing on the same timelines, which I don't think is realistic" — FSCAC member from the Securities and Exchange Commission
The DISA member said delays come from both agencies and providers. The SEC member also asked whether the priorities repeated work already on FedRAMP's roadmap. FedRAMP staff said they still wanted the committee's view, especially on small businesses. The SEC member voted no on the priorities. Four members abstained.
The chair then proposed subcommittees. Members said no. The SEC member said:
"We only have two priorities. We have a whole year to work on them." — FSCAC member from the Securities and Exchange Commission
What did members ask for next?
Members asked for data before they draft advice. Ideas included a survey of industry, the results of FedRAMP's annual survey, and informal talks with assessors, agencies, and providers. A GSA staff member said the committee may need to check a survey with its lawyers because of the Paperwork Reduction Act. The member from the Department of Veterans Affairs asked what two things FedRAMP hoped to finish in the next six months, and how it would measure success. The Google member asked for the FedRAMP Board's process plan.
The committee met next on July 16, 2024. On July 25, 2024, OMB issued M-24-15, Modernizing the Federal Risk and Authorization Management Program.
Sources
- FedXchange tracker: Federal Secure Cloud Advisory Committee (FSCAC) May 20, 2024 Meeting
- YouTube: Federal Secure Cloud Advisory Committee (FSCAC) May 20, 2024 Meeting
- GSA: FSCAC May 20, 2024, public meeting agenda and minutes
- GSA: FSCAC Annual Report to Congress and the GSA Administrator, December 2022 to May 2024 (PDF)
- GSA: Federal Secure Cloud Advisory Committee meetings
- GSA: Federal Secure Cloud Advisory Committee
- Federal Register: FSCAC notification of upcoming meeting, April 17, 2024 (2024-08086)
- FedXchange tracker: OMB M-24-15, Modernizing the Federal Risk and Authorization Management Program
- FedXchange tracker: FedRAMP Authorization Act (Public Law 117-263, section 5921)
- FedXchange tracker: FedRAMP Consolidated Rules for 2026
- FedRAMP: What's Changing in 2026
Get new posts and federal governance by email
A weekly email on Fridays, an alert on the day the watch finds something new, or both. Free.